The Sizzling Pickle Eatery & Lounge - Craig, Colorado

Susan A.

Went for late dinner and the waitress was SUPER friendly and attentive. Went about an hour before closing so maybe the food just wasn't as fresh then. Hate to say anything bad because the staff were so nice but the grilled chicken salad I had was really not good at all and my stomach hurt for several hours after eating it. The sandwiches my family had were all okay but the meat had a stale taste to it. The trio of pickles appetizer was good. The pickle
pasta salad was "okay". Fast service and attentive service. Neat little place.

Todd B.

This is a diner type restaurant with bar / diner food. The servers are very nice and helpful. The both items I had were good.
The Totchos (tatertot nachos) were excellent. We had pulled pork and brisket versions. Crispy tots and flavorful meats.
If you're in Craig give them a try. You won't be disappointed.

Adrienne Y.

Our food was good and the service was great! We had burgers, sliders, and tenders. Their pulled pork is a little different than we’re used to, it’s sliced rather than pulled or shredded, but it was tender and had good flavor. There were lots of people when we visited and it’s fun to visit a solid local spot. Thanks for a nice lunch!

Brandon D.

The tatnachos with beef brisket is amazing. The tots were still Crispy and the beef brisket added a sweet smokiness to the dish. Hands down one of my favorite nachos i have ever had.
The bloody marys are really good. I highly recommend ordering one. I ended up ordering 2. I would have ordered more but I needed to drive.
The fried pickle spears were ok. Half of them lost their breading and the oil got into the pickle, burning it and making to greasy. With this restaurant serving so many good looking apps, I would pass on the fried pickles.
I'll differently will coming back here when I'm back in town

Em R.

Order fried pickles. Chicken wings and fries. Husband got bone in I got bone out. Both came down with food poisoning. Waiter couldn't stay off her phone only checked on us twice. Had to walk the credit card to her cause she wasn't paying attention. Cute dinner though. Wish it was better.

Zach B.

The service was excellent! Friendly, patient, and helpful staff members. Then there’s the food! After a long day of hunting, nothing hits the spot like a thick, juicy burger!

I got the “POPPIN burger” (asked for a double patty), sriracha fries with honey mustard sauce, and a chocolate milkshake.

Altogether, the food was delicious, service was above and beyond, and the restaurant atmosphere was family friendly.

*Update - Jan 2022* Recently went to Craig again for our annual Elk hunt. Everything from my previous review holds up to date! This is hands down my favorite place to eat in Craig! 100% would recommend

Erin A.

Probably the best service I’ve ever had. All staff were genuinely amazing checking on you constantly but not disturbing in anyway
The wings are smoked which adds a depth of flavor to your standard buffalo wing regardless of the sauce you pick
I would recommend the garlic Parmesan
The jalapeño poppers we a hit and the fries are perfect. Get them with the “fry sauce”

Bob E.

Our waitress left after we ordered our food, never seen her again so another girl brought us our food but no more interactions afterwards. Food was good but prices i thought were too high. 65 bucks for a burger and a bottle corona for me and a 3 slider meal and a soda for my wife with a small order of deep fried spicy pickles (that werent spicy or were mistakenlymade as regular flavor). We ate Applebee's the previous night, with 2 ribeye dinners, 2 kids meals, 3 drinks, and a beer for same quality of food and price.