McGarity's Restaurant & Saloon ® -- Eureka Springs, AR - Eureka Springs, Arkansas

Paul Spicer

The waitress was nice offered good menu selections. The food was reasonable priced especially for the quality.

The setting was nice. The Irish Pub decor was impressive. The restaurant and restrooms were clean.

Minus a star only because we were seated in a cramped spot. We sat next to a couple in a cramped corner when there were many other open seating areas that would’ve boosted our experience. Understandable for the area in town though.

I will be back to try other menu items.

Dee Holladay

We were only in Eureka Springs for four days...we ate here twice!
Portions are generous, and the food is delicious!
My husband ordered the shrimp, fish and chips, I had the ribeye...which he got half of.
Unless you aren't a steak person, you are going to want to order the ribeye. It's 16oz. You may need to bring a friend to help you. It is so delicious, you aren't going to want to share. But it is big! Pairs excellently with a Guinness!
My sides were the green beans and the loaded mashed potatoes. Our second visit, I changed out the potato for a salad. Every side was delicious. The green beans and salad were my favorite.
The restaurant is lovely. The hand carved bar, gorgeous bar chairs, pretty mismatched plates, and cozy booths. Water is brought to your table in a ice cold glass bottle when you are seated.
There is even a shuffleboard table in the bar area. There is seating that is somewhat separated from the bar area. It's very cozy.
The staff is incredibly friendly and willing to take measures to accommodate.
The prices are reasonable...especially considering the portion size.
If we lived in Eureka Springs, this would definitely be a regular stop for us.

Legends Equestrian Center LEC

WOW! Best corned beef and mashed potatoes I’ve ever had EVER…. Husband got the fish and shrimp with chips and was the best he’s ever had. And it’s the only thing he ever orders at an Irish pub, so kind of an expert. Superb! Atmosphere fun and traditional even though newly done. A tad expensive and plates could be smaller to reduce the prices. I will return every time I return to Eureka Springs.

Leah Smith

We got the egg rolls and the fried green tomato’s as appetizers. And the McGarity’s burger and the pork chop as entrees. It was all amazing! Best food here so far! I am not a beer person but I got the Black Apple Hibiscus Cider craft beer and it was sooooo good, it doesn’t have a strong beer flavor!

Cindy Pruitt

What a wonderful restaurant! Amazing staff, the decorations were gorgeous and the food was outstanding! The prices may seem a bit high, but you get a lot of food for the price! Unlike many restaurants in Eureka, you leave very satisfied for the price and maybe even leftovers!

Marietta Cate

Great little spot for the authentic Irish pub atmosphere. The owner is a knowledgeable chap who gave us a Guinness education. The french fries are well seasoned & crispy but not overdone. The cheeseburger was really good "Hertzog" beef with a nice soft brioche bun. My partner in gastronomy education & experiments had the macaroni & cheese with crabmeat. I'm dying to try it all including the shepherd's pie. Blackened redfish is next. The carrot cake sure seemed fresh made, many layers tall, with a nice light whipped frosting. I get in touch with my Irish ancestry with the music.

Chicken salad on brioche bun is very good too. The Reuben sandwich is the best I've ever had. The portions are huge so you can't eat it all in one sitting. It's two meals in one. You'll love the gumbo with grits at the bottom & big pieces of crab claw.

Cayla Madaris

The vibe is top notch! Cool place. Good service and friendly people. I was disappointed they were out of the two things I wanted but I got the broccoli cheese soup which was good and I loved the bread. Card games at the tables is a great idea. The curry was also very good. Highly recommend!

Eddy Chavez

My wife and I first time here. Was not a disappointment? Have driven past it numerous times and kept saying, I need to stop in there and try it. AlrightI'm glad that I had time to sit down and eat will always come back great food