The Italian - Dolores, CO

Ingrid W.

CUTE PLACE ... I went on Fri 1-26-24 @ 4pm opening ... I thought it was really cute and quaint inside with about six tables for seating, both table and 1/2 booth style. I like that the water was already on the table in a corked bottle. I thought it was a nice touch. This is the first week of their full menu which includes pasta entries.

GOOD FOOD ... I got the pepperoni Detroit style pizza which I thought was really good and was huge! You could easily split that between four people, there were eight large slices. I ate two pieces and was pretty full, it's thick pizza. They serve bread as you are seated, which they don't make fresh in house, but was really good. I got water with my meal and it was just over $21 with tax. I took 3/4 home. Good deal on the pizza!

A neighboring table got the Chicken Francese and Chicken Cacciatore which both looked good, as did the side salads. The patrons that I asked about their orders nodded in approval. They were pretty steady with customers seating and picking up orders the entire time we were there.

I would definitely go again and try another dish.

Note I only gave three stars for service because it was the waitresses first day and she couldn't answer some of the questions which was okay, but then, she never got back with us on the questions either. The actual service itself was fine.

David K.

Was visiting in Dolores and decided to eat at the Italian. Quaint little restaurant in and old historic hotel which is in the process of renovations. The restaurant was fairly busy, but the staff was attentive and friendly. Hanna, our server, was very friendly and bubbly, and very welcoming. We found out it was her first night and had never waited tables before, but she did a great job. We were on a bike trip and all three of us loved the food and atmosphere. Food was all made from scratch and very reasonably priced, a pleasant surprise these days. We ordered the shrimp scampi, Detroit style pizza(amazing) and chicken parm. Along with a variety of desserts. Everything was outstanding! I highly recommend this place. To top it off, Marie, the owner was just so friendly, welcoming and nice to all that came in the restaurant. She truly makes you feel like family, and it shows in her food. I’ll definitely be back!

Siena G.

We were a late arrival, yet they took us in with warmth. The atmosphere was cozy and welcoming. The food was savory and included quality ingredients. With the current import market into our fairly remote area, the dishes are fairly priced. We will be returning with our family soon!

Tim C.

Detroit born, lived in West MI, S. Chicago, Savannah, Charleston, Portland and Cortez the last 20 yrs. Cortez for 10.

Man…Pizza was okay at best. Def overpriced. Def pre-made frozen dough. Ratios of dough, sauce and toppings are pretty bad. Tons of dough, too much cheese, buttered edges so it's crusty on the outside of the pan for appearance. Staff was super nice and attentive and kind. Kid's pasta with sauce (appeared to be the same sauce that was on the pizza…I'm guessing, which is weird) was nothing super special. Didn't really feel like anything better than cooking at home with Safeway noodles and some marinara for 8 bucks. Ordered 1 meatball and said they can only sell three in an order (after the fact) and just skipped putting them on the dish or asking us if we still wanted them as an order. Said they come pre packed in 3's…so that tells me they're not homemade either.

$ Total: 1 pizza, 1 kids pasta, 1 sprite, 1 beer - $47.00 + Tip = 54 bucks. Oof.

Prob won't be back as a longtime Cortez resident.
Best of luck to you all though. Anyone on this feed, restaurants in the SW are all super bad other than Thai. Sorry.

Danny H.

Great food, great people.
Ate here several times while in Delores Co.
The pizza was amazing and I really enjoyed the crispy Chicken Parmesan. All house made with fresh ingredients.
Two thumbs up from me.

C S.

My husband got the lasagna and I got the chicken piccata. Both plates were delicious and the side salad was fresh. We got the limoncello tiramisu to go. Yum!! A great addition to sweet Dolores!

Katie F.

An amazing addition to Dolores. The food is incredible (you really can’t go wrong with anything on the menu), and the service is always top notch. The dining space is a cozy vibe for dine-in, and takeout is easy, too. We are particularly partial to the pizza and chicken parmesan, but have truly enjoyed every dish we’ve tried.

We feel lucky to have The Italian in town, along with their whole team!

Lauren H.

I absolutely love Marie and her staff. They have a warm welcome, amazing food and a great menu selection on rotation per season.