Tuscany Tavern - Evergreen, Colorado

Valeria C.

The food was pretty good. My husband enjoyed the lasagna and I had the Cheese Ravioli - it says it has pesto and I didn't really catch the flavor in the dish because of it having so much sauce. It was still good. The house bread with garlic butter was fantastic!

Michael G.

Food was delicious some had a bit more breading than I like but normal for the dish. Sauces were excellent. Wine choices delightful and not overpriced (more than fair for a restaurant). My only complaint (and very minimal) was each of us got our salad dressing in a plastic cup [we need to use less plastic and more reusable]. We both had seafood and pasta dishes and both were first rate.

Emily S.

My daughters and I took a scenic trip to the mountains and needed a place to stop for dinner. We love Italian and this one obviously had good reviews so we made the trip to Evergreen.

Upon entering, we received smug looks from a couple waiting to be seated as well as plenty the staff who came to the front. It was clear that we were not their target audience (people were dressed nicely, there was a wedding party in a private room, and we were out exploring the mountains).

For a Saturday evening, I was expecting a longer wait time when asked "I'm sorry, do you have a reservation?" A 10-15 minute wait is what we were told. When we were finally seated, our waitress greeted us warmly and throughout our meal, we were made to feel welcome by her. She told me that she also had two daughters and that our girls night was adorable.

The food was absolutely delicious, but when we had asked for cheese for my daughter's noodles, they brought out a sauce and we thought that was strange instead of Parmesan. I also overheard them telling a lady that the cheese was in the kitchen, and maybe they could cut a piece off. Our meals had shredded cheese on top, so this made me curious.

We were offered dessert, which we gladly accepted. My daughters did not want to share, typical, and because they were extremely well behaved, I opted to get them their own.

Upon our table being cleared I was told by one of the girls who kept eyeing us "I've never seen a kid not finish their dessert." And "my sister and I never had a choice of sharing. We were told to share or get nothing."

I would have given this place 5-stars, but some of their staff (minus our lovely waitress ❤️) should be less judgemental.

Amber D.

First time takeout order. Two fettuccine and one pesto tortellini. They forgot the side salad, however, I thought it was the pesto tortellini they forgot because it came in the side salad box. Very disappointing. I called and was offered an apology but the tortellini is smaller than what i’d expect for an appetizer. I added artichoke and sun dried tomatoes (paid extra..expected ), but my pasta amount was reduced to accommodate the additions I paid extra for. Regardless of the taste, we will not be back.

Lindsey L.

Decided to try this place and I hate to say that the main entree was almost inedible. For starters, the appetizer we ordered was the garlic cheese bread and that was delicious. I had the Aglio Et Olio as my main entree with crispy chicken and it was the first time I’ve ever had to put my meal to the side after 3 bites. It had no flavor but was also bitter at the same time with a bit so great aftertaste.

Our waitress was kind and empathetic and was able to remove the meal from my tab, which I was grateful for.

The service was 10/10.
The food was 1/10.

Julie F.

We had dinner seated in a booth by the window downstairs and really enjoyed the view of the pond and pathway. I had Chicken Parmesan with Fettuccine and my husband had Meat Lasagna. The flatbread served before the meal was delicious! Our server was friendly. You can come casually dressed if you want to. It seems like a family friendly place also.

Ken E.

I’ve tried so many times for the last 20+ years and this place is always the same. The food takes forever and it’s rather tasteless. The service tries. I now drive 30 min to get decent strip mall Italian. And I won’t get into the drone of nonsensical political diatribes.

Timothy S.

This is the BEST homemade comfort food you’ll find! Her flavors are always so inventive and even unexpected and their presentation is simple and totally impressive (think—serve to guests!) I literally cannot get enough of her granola. The owner is super friendly and accommodating. Highly recommend starting an online order!